Electronic signature vs digital signature: what is the difference?
Electronic signature and digital signature get used as if they were synonyms — in sales calls, in contracts, even in legal articles. They are not. An electronic signature is a legal concept: any data in electronic form that a person uses to sign. A digital signature is a cryptographic technique that can sit behind an electronic signature, and often does not.
The confusion is harmless right up until it is not: when you are choosing signing software, when a signed document is challenged, or when a contract requires a specific signature level. This article explains both terms in plain words, shows how they connect under eIDAS, and leaves you with a short list of questions to ask any vendor before you trust them with your contracts.
Electronic signature: a legal concept
In the European Union the reference text is Regulation (EU) No 910/2014, better known as eIDAS. Article 3(10) defines an electronic signature as data in electronic form which is attached to or logically associated with other data in electronic form and which is used by the signatory to sign. Read that twice: there is not a single word about cryptography, certificates or any particular technology.
That breadth is deliberate. A typed name at the foot of an email, a squiggle drawn on a touchscreen, a click on an acceptance box inside a signing flow — all of these can be electronic signatures in the legal sense, provided the data expresses the signatory's intent to sign. What changes between them is not whether they count, but how much evidence they carry when someone disputes them. That is why eIDAS layers three levels on top of the base definition:
- Simple electronic signature (SES). Industry shorthand for anything that meets the basic definition but not the stricter requirements below. The regulation itself never actually uses the word simple.
- Advanced electronic signature (AES). Defined through Article 26, which sets four cumulative requirements: the signature is uniquely linked to the signatory, capable of identifying them, created under their sole control, and linked to the signed data so that any later change is detectable.
- Qualified electronic signature (QES). An advanced signature created with a qualified signature creation device and backed by a qualified certificate from a qualified trust service provider. Under Article 25(2) it has the equivalent legal effect of a handwritten signature.
Two more things are worth knowing. Article 25(1) establishes a non-discrimination principle: a signature cannot be denied legal effect or admissibility as evidence solely because it is electronic or because it is not qualified. And member states complement eIDAS with national law — in Spain, Ley 6/2020 governs how electronic documents are weighed as evidence in court.
Digital signature: a cryptographic technique
A digital signature is not a legal category at all. It is a technique from public key cryptography (PKI) for proving two things about a piece of data: who signed it and whether it has changed since. When a platform applies a digital signature to a document, roughly this happens:
- A hash of the document is computed — a short fingerprint that changes completely if even one character of the document changes.
- That hash is signed with the signer's private key, one half of a mathematically linked key pair. Only the holder of the private key can produce that signature.
- A digital certificate, issued by a certificate authority, binds the matching public key to an identity, so anyone verifying knows whose key it is.
- A verifier recomputes the hash of the document and checks it against the signed one. If the document was edited after signing — a figure changed, a clause removed — the hashes no longer match and verification fails visibly.
This is what cryptographic protection buys you: integrity, because tampering becomes detectable; authentication, because the signature ties back to a specific key and certificate; and non-repudiation, because it is hard for a signer to plausibly deny a signature made with a key only they control. None of this comes guaranteed with an electronic signature in general — it is precisely what the digital-signature technique adds.
You already rely on the same mathematics dozens of times a day. Your browser checks digitally signed certificates every time it opens an HTTPS page, and your operating system verifies that updates are digitally signed before installing them. Document signing simply points that same machinery at contracts.
How the two fit together
Every digital signature a person uses to sign a document is, legally speaking, an electronic signature. The reverse is not true: a simple electronic signature may involve no cryptography whatsoever. The cleanest way to put it is that electronic signature is the legal umbrella and digital signature is one technology under it — and it happens to be the technology that makes the upper eIDAS levels work. The Article 26 requirements for an advanced signature, in particular identifying the signatory and making any later change detectable, map almost one to one onto what PKI provides, which is why advanced and qualified signatures are built on digital signatures in practice. The eIDAS text itself stays deliberately technology-neutral.
When digital signatures are embedded in documents, standardised formats make them verifiable across tools. The European family is called AdES: PAdES for PDF files, XAdES for XML and CAdES for generic binary content, all standardised by ETSI. Each comes in baseline levels — from B-B (the signature itself) through B-T (adds a timestamp) up to B-LT and B-LTA (add validation material and archival timestamps) — so a signature can still be verified years later, even after the certificate behind it has expired.
Timestamps deserve a plain-words note of their own. Under RFC 3161, a trusted time-stamping authority receives a hash of your document and returns a signed token proving that the document existed, in exactly that state, before a given moment. eIDAS separately recognises the electronic time stamp as a means of establishing evidence in time. In everyday terms, a timestamp turns the question of when something was signed from a claim into something verifiable.
Side by side
Here is the whole article in one table.
| Electronic signature | Digital signature | |
|---|---|---|
| Concept | Legal: any electronic data used to sign | Technical: a cryptographic mechanism |
| Defined by | eIDAS, Article 3(10) | PKI practice and the ETSI AdES formats |
| Nature | Technology-neutral, split into levels (SES, AES, QES) | One specific technique: key pairs, certificates and hashes |
| Guarantees | Depend entirely on how it is implemented | Integrity and signer authentication by design |
| Examples | Typed name, drawn signature, acceptance click, AES, QES | A PAdES-sealed PDF, signed software updates, HTTPS certificates |
The two terms are not rivals, and one is not the upgraded version of the other. They answer different questions: does this count as signing, which is legal, and can I prove nothing changed afterwards, which is technical. A good signing process answers both.
Which one do you need?
The practical question is rarely electronic or digital. It is: how much evidence does this document need if it is ever disputed? For most everyday business paperwork — offers, NDAs, HR documents, service agreements — what gets weighed in practice is the evidence package: who signed, whether the document changed afterwards, and how the process ran. A simple or advanced electronic signature with a solid evidence trail covers that need; what matters is that your provider can demonstrate all three points. Before you commit to any vendor, ask them:
- Which eIDAS levels do you support — SES, AES, QES — and what does each look like inside your product?
- Is the final PDF cryptographically sealed, so that any edit after signing is detectable with a standard PDF reader?
- How do you identify signers — email access, one-time SMS codes, identity document checks?
- What evidence do I receive — timestamps, IP addresses, a complete audit trail — and can I export it if I ever leave?
- Where is my data hosted, and under which jurisdiction?
Cryptographic protection matters most when the counterparty might later deny signing, when the amounts involved are significant, or when a regulator may ask you to prove the integrity of a document. If you want the legal side in more depth, we cover how validity and evidence work and walk through the three eIDAS signature levels separately.
For transparency: this blog is written by Signatuz, an e-signature platform based in Madrid. Our approach is the one described above — every document signed ends up as a sealed PDF with timestamps (RFC 3161 where the configured flow supports it), IP and device capture, a complete audit trail and a signature certificate, with signer verification by email, one-time SMS code or an optional KYC identity check. Customer data is hosted on EU infrastructure.
Frequently asked questions
Is a scanned image of my handwritten signature a digital signature?
No. A pasted image works, at most, as a simple electronic signature: it may express intent, but it involves no cryptography, proves nothing about who placed it there and offers no tamper evidence. Anyone with the image file can reproduce it on any document.
Does agreeing to a deal over WhatsApp count as a signature?
It can carry evidential weight. The eIDAS definition is broad enough that a message expressing clear consent may qualify as an electronic signature, and courts do weigh chat messages as evidence. The hard part is proving who actually sent it and that the conversation was not altered, so for anything material, use a process built to capture that evidence.
Can a PDF prove that it was tampered with?
A cryptographically sealed PDF can. The seal is a digital signature over the file, so any later change breaks verification and standard PDF readers flag it. A plain, unsealed PDF cannot prove anything about its own history — it can be edited without a trace.
Do I need to buy a personal certificate to sign documents?
For most business documents, no. A signing platform applies the cryptographic protection on its side and captures identity evidence for each signer, so recipients only need a secure link. Personal qualified certificates come into play when a transaction specifically requires a qualified signature.
Is a digital signature always legally stronger than an electronic one?
The comparison does not quite work, because the two terms live on different planes. Legal weight comes from the eIDAS level and the evidence behind a signature; the digital signature is the technique that makes the higher levels possible. A well-evidenced advanced signature is strong precisely because it uses digital-signature technology.
